Current:Home > ScamsVirginia judge to decide whether state law considers embryos as property-InfoLens
Virginia judge to decide whether state law considers embryos as property
View Date:2024-12-23 17:29:23
FAIRFAX, Va. (AP) — A trial is underway in Virginia that will determine whether state law allows frozen embryos to be considered property that can be divided up and assigned a monetary value.
Fairfax County Circuit Court Judge Dontae Bugg heard arguments Thursday from a divorced couple who disagree over the ex-wife’s desire to use two embryos that they created when they were married.
Honeyhline Heidemann says the embryos are her last chance to conceive a biological child after a cancer treatment left her infertile. Jason Heidemann, says he does not want to be forced to become a biological father to another child.
The case attracted national attention last year when a different judge, Richard Gardiner, ruled that embryos could be considered “goods or chattel” that could be divided under state law, and his analysis relied in part on a 19th-century law governing the treatment of slaves.
Gardiner is no longer assigned to the case, for reasons unrelated to his citation of slavery as a precedent.
The case also comes as reproductive rights activists have expressed alarm over a ruling from the Alabama Supreme Court that found embryos could be considered children under that state’s law.
There is little case law in Virginia governing the treatment of embryos.
Honeyhline Heidemann’s suit was brought under a partition statute that governs the division of property between interested parties.
Jason Heidemann’s lawyer, Carrie Patterson, argued that there is no precedent for it because that law is not designed to deal with embryos. Its primary purpose, she said, is to govern the division of real estate.
Case law that exists nationally regarding embryos recognizes that they are not mere property, she said, but rather property with special characteristics that require courts to balance competing interests.
One of the things a judge must consider when evaluating such cases is a person’s “right to procreational autonomy.” In this case, Patterson said, her client has a strong interest in avoiding procreating against his will.
Honeyhline’s Heidemann’s attorney, Jason Zellman, argued that the partition statute applies if the embryos are classified as property, and if they can be assigned a monetary value.
Documents that both Heidemanns signed with the IVF provider specifically refer to the embryos as property, he said, and thus their value can be assessed as the cost incurred in their creation.
Because there are two embryos, he added, the judge has an easy means of dividing up the property: Award one embryo to each party.
Bugg, who said he will issue a ruling at a later date, expressed misgivings about the notion of assigning a monetary value to the embryos.
Zellman acknowledged that the case presents some novel issues, but he also suggested to the judge that it doesn’t need to “blaze the headlines” or establish any sweeping precedent. He said the unique facts of the Heidemanns’ case — including language in their divorce settlement requiring the embryos to remain in storage “pending a court order” — will distinguish it from future disputes.
The judge readily accepted that notion, saying, “I don’t think anything I do in this case applies to anyone but the Heidemanns.”
veryGood! (79)
Related
- Mike Tomlin's widely questioned QB switch to Russell Wilson has quieted Steelers' critics
- Health is on the agenda at UN climate negotiations. Here's why that's a big deal
- In Mexico, a Japanese traditional dancer shows how body movement speaks beyond culture and religion
- How a quadruple amputee overcame countless rejections to make his pilot dreams take off
- More than 150 pronghorns hit, killed on Colorado roads as animals sought shelter from snow
- Ewers throws 4 TDs as No. 7 Texas bids farewell to Big 12 with 49-21 title win over Oklahoma State
- COVID-19 now increasing again, especially in Midwest and Mid-Atlantic, CDC says
- Florida Republican chairman won’t resign over rape allegation, saying he is innocent
- 'I know how to do math': New Red Lobster CEO says endless shrimp deal is not coming back
- A suspected bomb blast kills at least 3 Christian worshippers in southern Philippines
Ranking
- Ariana Grande's Brunette Hair Transformation Is a Callback to Her Roots
- In US, some Muslim-Jewish interfaith initiatives are strained by Israel-Hamas war
- Report: Contaminants being removed from vacant Chicago lot where migrant housing is planned
- The 10 best quarterbacks in college football's transfer portal
- Dwayne Johnson Admits to Peeing in Bottles on Set After Behavior Controversy
- Burkina Faso rights defender abducted as concerns grow over alleged clampdown on dissent
- Authorities identify suspect in killing of 3 homeless men in Los Angeles
- If you're having a panic attack, TikTokers say this candy may cure it. Experts actually agree.
Recommendation
-
Guns smuggled from the US are blamed for a surge in killings on more Caribbean islands
-
Former prep school teacher going back to prison for incident as camp counselor
-
Wisconsin never trails in impressive victory defeat of No. 3 Marquette
-
Shannen Doherty says cancer has spread to her bones: I don't want to die
-
Wendi McLendon-Covey talks NBC sitcom 'St. Denis Medical' and hospital humor
-
7.6 magnitude earthquake strikes off the southern Philippines and a tsunami warning is issued
-
Jim Harbaugh set for $1.5 million in bonuses after Michigan beats Iowa for Big Ten title
-
Sister Wives' Janelle Brown Shares the One Thing She’d Change About Her Marriage to Kody